Clinical evaluation working guide
CER Literature Search Protocol: Questions, PICO and Search Records
A CER literature search protocol defines the evidence questions and planned retrieval, selection and appraisal methods before the search results are interpreted. It should enable another reviewer to understand what was sought, how it was found and why records were included.
This practical guide focuses on the protocol and audit trail. It is distinct from a full state-of-the-art discussion or a generic article about the value of literature reviews.
Frame separate device and clinical-context questions
Start with the claim, population, intended use and decision the evidence needs to support. A device-specific safety question may require different sources and terms from a treatment-landscape question. Keep those purposes visible so one broad search does not become the undocumented answer to every CER question.
PICO—population, intervention, comparator and outcomes—is one useful framing tool. It is not a requirement to force every device question into the same formula. For diagnostic or noncomparative evidence, adapt the question structure and explain the choice. Do not claim that the MDR mandates a named PICO format.
Design search concepts without hiding relevant evidence
Build concept groups for the device and its alternative names, the clinical condition or use, and the outcomes or risks relevant to the question. Translate the strategy for each database’s vocabulary and syntax. A strategy copied between platforms without adaptation may not retrieve the same evidence.
Before applying date, language or study-design restrictions, explain why they are appropriate and what relevant evidence could be lost. Test the strategy against known relevant papers. If a term change is needed, record the reason and retain the earlier strategy so the final methods can be reconstructed.
Specify screening and appraisal before synthesis
The protocol should distinguish eligibility decisions from quality appraisal. Define inclusion and exclusion criteria, duplicate handling, title/abstract and full-text stages, who makes decisions, how disagreements are resolved, and which exclusion reasons will be recorded. State the actual review arrangement; do not claim independent duplicate screening if it is not performed.
Appraisal should consider the study’s relevance to the evaluated device and question as well as its methodological limitations. Plan the extraction fields needed for claims, endpoints, population, follow-up, safety findings and uncertainty. A list of included papers is not yet an analysis of what their evidence supports.
Keep the search reproducible and updateable
Retain the database and platform, exact strategy, search date, limits, retrieved record count, export file, deduplication method and screening decisions. Document the evidence cut-off and any supplementary searching. Keep the source files and final report consistent; a polished methods paragraph cannot replace missing logs.
For an update, distinguish newly retrieved records from previously assessed evidence and explain any change in methods. Our CER update service can scope the handoff between the new search period and the existing report. If the CEP does not yet define the evidence questions, start with CEP writing support.
A compact protocol handover checklist
Before starting, confirm the question map, source selection, complete strategies, eligibility rules, appraisal plan and extraction fields. Before closing, confirm the exports, selection log, full-text exclusions, appraisal records, evidence tables and synthesis are linked and versioned. Agree the reference-library format and full-text access responsibilities at quotation stage.
IMTS supports complete reviews or defined stages of the workflow. The scope should state the databases, evidence period, review arrangement, deliverables and comment rounds so the manufacturer knows what it can reproduce and what remains its responsibility.
Common questions
Is PICO mandatory for every CER search?
No single named question framework is mandatory for every device question. PICO can help structure an appropriate question, but the protocol should fit the clinical purpose and explain its methods.
Which databases must every CER use?
There is no universal database list suitable for every device and question. Select and justify sources, document the platforms and strategies, and assess whether the approach captures relevant evidence.
Can IMTS support only one review stage?
Yes. Protocol development, searching, screening, appraisal, extraction or synthesis can be scoped individually. The quotation identifies responsibilities, outputs and handover materials.
Primary regulatory sources
- Regulation (EU) 2017/745: Article 61, Annex XIV and Article 120
- MEDDEV 2.7/1 Rev 4: clinical evaluation guidance
Check the applicable consolidated legislation and current guidance for the device. Guidance supports interpretation; it does not replace the MDR or a device-specific assessment.
Connected services and working guides
For the complete evaluation package, see IMTS Clinical Evaluation Report writing services.
- Clinical Evaluation Plan (CEP) Writing Services
- CER Update Services for EU MDR
- CER Template for EU MDR: A Practical Report Outline
For protocol development or an agreed review stage, explore IMTS systematic literature review services. For integration of the findings into clinical evaluation, see CER writing support.
Book a Scoping Call